| How the 5M Framework Is Shaping Treatment for Older Adults

| Lauren Schneider

| Substance use disorder is on the rise among older adults. Between 2000 and 2020, overdose death rates from all drugs among adults 65 and older rose from 2.4 to 8.8 per 100,000 people. While opioid overdose deaths have declined in recent years, that progress has been slower for seniors.

Treatment providers across the country are taking notice. Just over 7 percent of addiction clinics had dedicated programs for older adults in 2012, according to a national survey of service providers. By 2019, nearly 25 percent of facilities had these services. Communities including Baltimore and the state of Pennsylvania set aside funds from settlements with opioid manufacturers to support overdose prevention initiatives for older adults. And in 2020, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration released guidelines for treating senior substance use disorder.

As substance use programs tailor offerings to older adults, more elder care practitioners are learning to treat substance use disorder. Kimberly Beiting, an assistant professor at Vanderbilt University Medical Center, holds workshops on substance use at an annual nursing home conference. “Every year, we’ve gotten more and more interest,” she said. “People say this is definitely an issue in [their] facilities.”

To determine the best course of treatment, geriatricians like Beiting consider a patient’s circumstances through the 5M framework, accounting for mental state, mobility, medications, multicomplexities and what matters most to the patient. The unique challenges in treating older adults with substance use disorders can be understood through these categories.

Mental state

Mental state refers to a patient’s cognitive or mood symptoms. Since both age-related changes and substance use can affect a patient’s mental state, clinicians trained to manage only one of these influences may not be seeing the full picture.

Providers at two San Diego opioid clinics identified age-related cognitive decline as a challenge to productive therapeutic relationships, according to a study published earlier this year based on interviews with staff and older patients. Conversely, elder care providers may miss drug-related cognitive changes by chalking a patient’s symptoms up to age, Beiting said.

Mobility

Beiting noted that frequent falls are another indicator of substance use disorder that may be ascribed solely to a patient’s age.

While a patient’s physical condition and fall risk represent one aspect of mobility, the term also encompasses a person’s access to transportation, which the respondents in the San Diego opioid clinic study described as an obstacle to treatment.

“Addiction clinics were not built with older adults in mind,” said study author Wayne Kepner, now an instructor at Stanford University. “For an older adult who gave up their keys, [a facility] not being on a bus line can mean the difference between going to treatment or not.”

An elderly hand holding white tablets with a prescription bottle pouring more pills into the palm, set against a textured gray surface.
Towfiqu Barbhuiya via Unsplash

Multicomplexity

Multicomplexity refers to the unique social and medical factors shaping a patient’s situation. Without this holistic perspective, a provider might misunderstand a patient’s needs.

For example, some diagnostic frameworks are more relevant to seniors than others. The DSM-V criteria for substance use disorders contains items about home or family responsibilities that might not apply to older patients, Beiting said.

Providers may not even screen older patients for alcohol and drug use. “We have this bias that older people don’t use drugs,” Kepner said. “That [bias] trickles down to clinicians.”

Many of today’s older adults are Baby Boomers who came of age in the 1960s and 1970s, when recreational drug use was “very prevalent” compared to previous generations, said Minhee Sung, an assistant professor at Yale School of Medicine who studies opioid use disorder in older adults. Patients treated for opioid use disorder may use other illicit drugs.

Medication

Prescription medications can also complicate a patient’s case. Over 40 percent of Americans aged 65 and older took five or more prescription drugs daily in 2020, per an analysis in JAMA Internal Medicine.

Older adults take prescription opioids for chronic pain, and if use becomes problematic, it can be hard to manage both pain and opioid-related risk. “It becomes a really interesting balancing act,” Sung said.

Doctors may prescribe medications to combat opioid use disorder itself. In 2023, the Drug Enforcement Administration phased out the “X-waiver,” an extra certification for prescribing buprenorphine (also known as naloxone or Suboxone, an increasingly medication for treating common treat opioid use disorder by normalizing brain chemistry and relieving physiological cravings) on top of the standard DEA license. While license holders undergo mandatory training that describes these new rules, Beiting said she still meets providers at long-term care facilities who are unconfident about prescribing the medication.

Not all patients are interested in buprenorphine. According to Sung, age-related changes to kidney and liver function may make older patients more sensitive to the medication’s side effects, which can include sleepiness, slow breathing and falls. She noted that the stigma around buprenorphine can affect the care older patients receive from other providers.

What matters most

There is no one-size-fits-all alternative for people who do not wish to take buprenorphine, Sung said, adding that providers should focus on what matters most to the patient.

Beiting helps patients determine what matters most through conversations about their long-term goals and steps for reaching them, though she said this planning might be more difficult than it is for other older adults because it can be harder to find an emergency contact or someone to serve as power of attorney. People with a history of substance use may be estranged from their families or have lost close friends to overdose.

Despite the difficult, nuanced work of finding the best path forward for seniors with substance use disorders, providers can find it rewarding to navigate these messy realities. “There’s an infinite amount of work to be done with the limited resources that we have, but it’s definitely worthwhile,” Sung said. “Everyone deserves excellent, equitable care.”

Lauren Schneider is a freelance science journalist based in New York City. Her work has appeared in Scientific American, Texas Monthly and more.


Discover more from Aging in America News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply